Tweet
It doesn't exist yet - at least I don't think so. I'll start with the ones I have and just make stuff up about the rest: 
BFD2 Pros: the kicks and snares absolutely rock. Crashes, splashes and Chinas are stellar. Mappable. Powerful FX. Up to 32 kit pieces.
Excellent mixing capabilities. Cons: some of the toms, rides and hats behave erratically and sound fake. MIDI LEARN and a few other functions just plain don't work for me. Most kits have only 3 toms, so if you want to add a 4th you have to retune one. Unless you know a fair amount about about EQ, Compression, Limiiting, Saturation and Reverb, it's best to leave the FX alone. Presets are few and iffy. I like but don't love it.
ADDICTIVE DRUMS Pros: most kit pieces are superb - particularly the toms and cymbals. Tons of decent FX and presets. They're well-named too - you know from the name what the preset will sound like. All kits have four toms. Very configurable - great mixer. Fairly inexpensive - $250 or less. Cons: Snares and kicks sound good by themselves, but tend to get lost in a mix. They lose a little depth and presence when paired with other instruments. Hard-mapped, although it works well with a MIDI mapper. Limited kit pieces. Overall, my favorite so far.
SUPERDRUMFX Pros: the only one out of the bunch specifically designed for edrummers. Completely mappable and easy-to-use. FREEWARE! What about 90% of you that are rushing out to buy S2 should learn to use first. Cons: only two velocity layers. Samples are too small to really sound that good, but I still think it sounds better than some stock TD kits. Limited kit pieces.
The rest is hearsay, conjecture and possibly blasphemy:
SUPERIOR 2 Can't say I've been that impressed with demos on the site or posted here. There's a sameness to the drums that doesn't sit well with me, mostly the toms. It would be nice to hear some wav demos to get a better impression. A pox on the guy who invented mp3's. Many of you appear to be lost without Joe (SP, Pim and a few others excepted). Seems to have limited content with the knowledge that you'll always buy more. The jury's still out for me.
EZDrummer Don't know much about it, but it sounds pretty good, IMHO. The kit piece limit is a deal-killer for me. Seems like you get a lot for your money, but something also that you would soon outgrow.
MIXOSAURUS Immensely impressed with the demos. Really in another league from the above products (as reflected by the price). Dev appears to want to perfect the product for edrummers. On the downside, it's just ONE kit! Seems like it would take an enormous amount of tweaking to get a decent variety of kit sounds. Semi-limited kit pieces, too. Great as the samples are, these limitations make it just too pricey and resource-intensive for my consideration - for now.
OCEAN WAY DRUMS Still a work in progress, but appear to be headed in the right direction. To my ears, the samples are of the same super-high quality as MIXO, but you get 19 different and distinct kits and you can mix and match. Right now it's geared towards keyboard drummers and TD-20 users only; this supposedly will change with future releases. Also, in its present state it has limited kit pieces - ONE CRASH CYMBAL, FFS! Again, it appears they've seen the error of their ways and are adding features as they go. The jury's still out on this one, too.
What say you all?
Steve
BFD2 Pros: the kicks and snares absolutely rock. Crashes, splashes and Chinas are stellar. Mappable. Powerful FX. Up to 32 kit pieces.
Excellent mixing capabilities. Cons: some of the toms, rides and hats behave erratically and sound fake. MIDI LEARN and a few other functions just plain don't work for me. Most kits have only 3 toms, so if you want to add a 4th you have to retune one. Unless you know a fair amount about about EQ, Compression, Limiiting, Saturation and Reverb, it's best to leave the FX alone. Presets are few and iffy. I like but don't love it.
ADDICTIVE DRUMS Pros: most kit pieces are superb - particularly the toms and cymbals. Tons of decent FX and presets. They're well-named too - you know from the name what the preset will sound like. All kits have four toms. Very configurable - great mixer. Fairly inexpensive - $250 or less. Cons: Snares and kicks sound good by themselves, but tend to get lost in a mix. They lose a little depth and presence when paired with other instruments. Hard-mapped, although it works well with a MIDI mapper. Limited kit pieces. Overall, my favorite so far.
SUPERDRUMFX Pros: the only one out of the bunch specifically designed for edrummers. Completely mappable and easy-to-use. FREEWARE! What about 90% of you that are rushing out to buy S2 should learn to use first. Cons: only two velocity layers. Samples are too small to really sound that good, but I still think it sounds better than some stock TD kits. Limited kit pieces.
The rest is hearsay, conjecture and possibly blasphemy:
SUPERIOR 2 Can't say I've been that impressed with demos on the site or posted here. There's a sameness to the drums that doesn't sit well with me, mostly the toms. It would be nice to hear some wav demos to get a better impression. A pox on the guy who invented mp3's. Many of you appear to be lost without Joe (SP, Pim and a few others excepted). Seems to have limited content with the knowledge that you'll always buy more. The jury's still out for me.
EZDrummer Don't know much about it, but it sounds pretty good, IMHO. The kit piece limit is a deal-killer for me. Seems like you get a lot for your money, but something also that you would soon outgrow.
MIXOSAURUS Immensely impressed with the demos. Really in another league from the above products (as reflected by the price). Dev appears to want to perfect the product for edrummers. On the downside, it's just ONE kit! Seems like it would take an enormous amount of tweaking to get a decent variety of kit sounds. Semi-limited kit pieces, too. Great as the samples are, these limitations make it just too pricey and resource-intensive for my consideration - for now.
OCEAN WAY DRUMS Still a work in progress, but appear to be headed in the right direction. To my ears, the samples are of the same super-high quality as MIXO, but you get 19 different and distinct kits and you can mix and match. Right now it's geared towards keyboard drummers and TD-20 users only; this supposedly will change with future releases. Also, in its present state it has limited kit pieces - ONE CRASH CYMBAL, FFS! Again, it appears they've seen the error of their ways and are adding features as they go. The jury's still out on this one, too.
What say you all?
Steve
Comment